Gosh Taryn, I know its confusing, as Facebook still refers to the vertical banner on your Page as your Page Profile Picture. This post is intended to help you maximize your visual branding of the vertical banner on your Facebook (Fan) Page. Sounds like you are working on your Personal Profile. If yes, then you need to upload a photograph of yourself and square-shaped. Does that help you?
Not bad. Especially like the animation. Unfortunately, elementary school has become like the world and will remain so until defending the innocent (instead of turning them into political pawns) becomes fashionable again.